Beware of trees: Pine afforestation of a naturally treeless habitat reduces flower and pollinator diversity

Abstract

Planting three billion trees to capture carbon and seeking measures to reverse pollinator decline are two key pledges of the EU Biodiversity Strategy for 2030. Although planting trees could be adequate to restore biodiversity in degraded landscapes and mitigate anthropogenic carbon emissions, it can also negatively impact biodiversity of naturally treeless habitats. To explore whether these two pledges might conflict, we focused on the European dry heathland, a treeless habitat frequent in the southwestern Iberian Peninsula, where it is locally known as herriza. The herriza stands out by its high plant biodiversity and profuse flowering that supports a wide range of insect pollinators. Yet, the herriza has been heavily afforested with pine trees until the onset of the 21st century. This past activity provides a unique natural experiment to assess the effect of afforestation on flower abundance and associated pollinator diversity. We conducted a two-year field study of the diversity and abundance of flowers and pollinators in five selected sites, each consisting of two adjacent plots of open and afforested herriza. Afforested herriza plots had consistently lower diversity and abundance of flowers and insect pollinators than open herriza plots. Our results highlight the negative impact of afforestation of a treeless habitat on its flowering pattern and associated insect pollinator guilds. We thus suggest seeking alternatives to afforesting naturally treeless habitats in order to avoid conflicts between carbon sequestration and pollinator conservation.